Reflections on the Mysterion (Sacrament) of Confession

My beloved spiritual children in Christ Our Only True God and Our Only True Savior,
CHRIST IS IN OUR MIDST! HE WAS, IS, AND EVER SHALL BE.

+

 

REFLECTIONS ON THE MYSTERION (SACRAMENT) OF CONFESSION
By Protopresbyter Alexander Schmemann

For each conscientious priest, Confession is without any doubt one of the most difficult and frustrating aspects of his ministry. It is here, on the one hand, that he encounters the only real object of his Pastoral care: the human soul, man, as he stands sinful and miserable, before God. But it is here, on the other hand, that he realizes to what degree nominal Christianity has pervaded our Church life. The basic Christian notions of sin and repentance, reconciliation with God and renewal of life, seem to have become irrelevant. If the terms are still used, their meaning is certainly quite different from that, on which our whole Christian faith is based.

Another source of difficulties is the theoretical, or even theological, confusion as to the nature of the Sacrament of Penance. In practice, a purely formal and juridical understanding of it, clearly Western and "romanizing" in its origin, coexists paradoxically with an equally doubtful reduction of confession to psychology. In the first case, the man comes to the priest, confesses transgressions of Christian law, and receives absolution which entitles him to the second sacrament "of obligation" - Holy Communion. Confession proper is reduced here to a minimum, and in some churches even replaced by a general formula to be read by the penitent. If the first case reveals "romanizing" tendencies, the second can be termed "protestantizing". Confession is regarded as "counseling," as helping and solving difficulties and problems and is a dialogue not between man and God, but between man and a supposedly wise and experienced advisor with ready answers to all human problems. Both tendencies, however, obscure and deform the truly Orthodox understanding and practice of Confession.

The existing situation is due to many factors. And, although it is obviously impossible to enumerate all of them here and to even outline the very complicated historical development of the Mysterion (Sacrament) of Penance/Confession, a few remarks are necessary before we discuss possible solutions.

a) Originally the Sacrament of Penance/Confession was understood and practiced as reconciliation of those excommunicated, i.e., banished from the "Ecclesia" -the Assembly of the People of God and its fulfillment in the Divine Eucharist which is the "Koinonia" of the Body and Blood of Christ. The excommunicated is the one who cannot offer and, therefore, cannot receive. This reconciliation was a long process and the absolution -- its final seal, the sign or "image" of repentance, i.e., of the rejection and condemnation by the penitent of his sin and alienation from God, of its real confession (manifestation, recognition) as sin. The power of absolution was not thought of as a "power in itself", virtually independent from repentance. It was indeed the Sacramental sign of an acceptance and that God has accepted it, has "reconciled and united" the penitent with the Church. Whatever changes occurred in the practice of the Sacrament, this first and essential meaning, is still the starting point of its Orthodox Christian understanding.

(To be continued)

________________________

"Glory Be To GOD For All Things!" -- Saint John Chrysostom

+++

With sincere agape in His Holy Diakonia (Ministry),
The sinner and unworthy servant of God

+Father George

Previous
Previous

Rules for a Saving Confession

Next
Next

The First Week of Great and Holy Lent: Monday to Friday